Unsubsidized wind energy is significantly cheaper than electricity from new-build coal- and gas-fired power stations in Australia, finds a new analysis from Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF).
The study modeled the cost of generating electricity in Australia from different sources. The data shows that electricity can be supplied from a new wind farm at a cost of AUD 80/MWh, compared to AUD 143/MWh from a new coal plant or AUD 116/MWh from a new baseload gas plant, including the cost of emissions under the government's carbon pricing scheme.
However, even without a carbon price, wind energy is 14% cheaper than new coal and 18% cheaper than new gas, BNEF says.
“The perception that fossil fuels are cheap and renewables are expensive is now out of date,” says Michael Liebreich, CEO of BNEF. “The fact that wind power is now cheaper than coal and gas in a country with some of the world’s best fossil-fuel resources shows that clean energy is a game changer which promises to turn the economics of power systems on its head.”
In Australia, the cost of wind energy generation has fallen by 10%, and the cost of solar photovoltaics has dropped by 29%, since 2011, BNEF says. In contrast, the cost of energy from new fossil-fueled plants is high and rising.
For instance, new coal is made expensive by high financing costs. BNEF’s study surveyed Australia’s four largest banks and found that lenders are unlikely to finance new coal without a substantial risk premium, due to the reputational damage of emissions-intensive investments - if they even finance coal at all.
Meanwhile, new gas-fired generation is expensive, as the massive expansion of Australia’s liquefied-natural-gas export market forces local prices upwards. The carbon price adds further costs to new coal- and gas-fired plants, and is forecast to increase substantially over the lifetime of a new facility.
By 2020, large-scale solar PV will also be cheaper than coal and gas, when carbon prices are factored in, and by 2030, dispatchable renewable generating technologies, such as biomass and solar thermal, could also be cost-competitive, BNEF adds.
The results suggest that the Australian economy is likely to be powered extensively by renewable energy in the future and that investment in new fossil-fuel power generation may be limited - unless there is a sharp and sustained fall in Asia-Pacific natural-gas prices.
“It is very unlikely that new coal-fired power stations will be built in Australia - they are just too expensive now, compared to renewables,” says Kobad Bhavnagri, head of clean energy research for BNEF in Australia. “Even baseload gas may struggle to compete with renewables. Australia is unlikely to require new baseload capacity until after 2020, and by this time, wind and large-scale PV should be significantly cheaper than burning expensive, export-priced gas.
“By 2020-2030, we will be finding new and innovative ways to deal with the intermittency of wind and solar, so it is quite conceivable that we could leapfrog straight from coal to renewables to reduce emissions as carbon prices rise,” he adds. “New wind is cheaper than building new coal and gas, but cannot compete with old assets that have already been paid off. For that reason, policy support is still needed to put megawatts in the ground today and build up the skills and experience to de-carbonize the energy system in the long term.”