in News Departments > Policy Watch
print the content item



The wind energy production tax credit (PTC) has become a key wedge issue in the 2012 presidential campaign - especially in Iowa, the No. 1 state in the U.S. for wind energy jobs and No. 2 in the nation in installed wind power capacity.

Until now, both President Barack Obama and Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney have been clear about their polar-opposite positions on the PTC.

Obama has made the tax credit one of the cornerstones of his campaign in states like Iowa and Colorado, both of which have an established wind energy supply chain and depend heavily on the PTC to keep thousands of wind jobs. In fact, Obama even made the passage of a PTC extension part of Congress’ to-do list - a task it has so far failed to accomplish.

Meanwhile, Romney said in July that he was in favor of letting the wind energy PTC expire at the end of this year. When speaking in Iowa at a campaign event last week, however, Romney suggested that he would support a phase-out of the wind energy PTC.

“We will support nuclear and renewables but phase out subsidies once an industry is on its feet,” Romney said last Friday.

A PTC phase-out has gained traction as a possible bipartisan compromise and has been supported by Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus, who is also leading the efforts to push through an omnibus tax-extenders bill that contains a one-year PTC extension.

However, Romney’s comment is in stark contrast from what was stated on his website back in July: “We should not be in the business of steering investment toward particular politically favored approaches,” his official position on energy read. “That is a recipe for both time and money wasted on projects that do not bring us dividends. The failure of wind mills and solar plants to become economically viable or make a significant contribution to our energy supply is a prime example.”

Those statements have been removed from Romney’s website; however, there are still no references to the PTC. The sole mention of wind energy comes in the following statement: “Companies like Solyndra have gone bankrupt, and the wind industry has shed 10,000 jobs.”

Many of those “shed jobs” have come in Iowa: Siemens and Clipper Windpower are just two examples of companies that have recently announced layoffs in Iowa due to the lack of a PTC extension.

At the second presidential debate, held earlier this month, Romney referenced those Iowa wind jobs.

“I don’t have a policy of stopping wind jobs in Iowa, and they’re not phantom jobs - they’re real jobs,” he said. “I appreciate wind jobs in Iowa and across our country.”

The state has bipartisan support for the wind energy PTC, including from Republicans Sen. Chuck Grassley, Gov. Terry Branstad and Rep. Steve King.

So with the Iowa race in a dead heat - the latest polling numbers put the state’s decision within the margin of error - could Romney have changed his mind about the wind energy PTC?

According to Frank Maisano, an energy analyst and founding partner at Bracewell & Giuliani's Policy Resolution Group, there may have been a change to Romney’s policy.

Although Iowa’s tight race may have influenced Romney’s comments, Maisano says, there is a larger issue at play.

“I think that, more importantly, it is reflective of congressional politics,” he notes, adding that the Senate Finance Committee passed the PTC-extension provision with bipartisan support.

“I think it’s more a reflection of the political reality of the situation versus any immediate opportunism,” he adds, “although I’m sure there’s a little bit of opportunism in it too."



Trachte Inc._id1770
Latest Top Stories

Senate Passes Tax Extenders Bill With Wind PTC Extension

The legislation, which passed in the U.S. House earlier this month, will renew the critical production tax credit through the end of 2014 - giving developers only about two weeks left to start construction.


Transmission Study Shows Nebraska Could Handle A Lot More Wind Power

A new report released by the Nebraska Power Review Board finds that the state already has enough infrastructure to accommodate at least 2 GW of additional wind generation.


Can Wind Energy And Birds Coexist? Environmental Group Says Yes

The Environmental Defense Fund, a supporter of responsible wind energy development, points out ways to help mitigate impacts of turbines on birds and bats.


Another Study Finds Wind Turbines Do Not Affect Nearby Property Values

Research conducted by the University of Guelph focused on regions in Ontario, and the conclusion echoes that of previous studies.


Too Little, Too Late? U.S. House Approves Wind PTC Extension

The U.S. House of Representatives has passed a tax extenders package that would renew the wind production tax credit (PTC) and about 50 other expired tax breaks through 2014. The wind industry argues the short-term fix is virtually no fix at all.

Hybrid Energy Innovations 2015