in News Departments > New & Noteworthy
print the content item



An effort by the Canadian government to study the impact of wind turbine noise on human health has gotten off to a rocky beginning, as some suggest the study's scope and cost have grown beyond the its original parameters.

In July, Health Canada announced that it would focus on an initial target sample size of 2,000 dwellings, selected from eight to 12 wind turbine facilities in Canada.

In addition to taking physical measurements - such as blood pressure - from participants, investigators will conduct face-to-face interviews and take noise measurements both inside and outside of homes in order to validate sound modeling. The results of the study are expected to be released in 2014.

However, according to a source attending last week's Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA) Conference & Exhibition in Toronto, the cost of the study has grown far beyond the C$1.8 million in funding the agency allocated to it.

"By the time everyone's feedback is taken into account, the study is going to run well beyond the funding that Health Canada has set aside," says the source, who requested not to be named. "I wouldn't be surprised if the study dies quietly on the vine."

However, Health Canada spokesperson Stephane Shank disagrees.

"Until a full review of all comments is completed, it would be premature and inappropriate to form such a basis of opinion,” he says.

He adds that Health Canada is currently reviewing more than 1,800 pages of feedback - plus attachments - following the public comment period that ended Sept. 7.

The feedback has been sent to a committee of experts overseeing the study. Responses to the feedback will be posted on Health Canada’s website and will include responses to comments relating to the study’s scope. However, Shank did not offer a timetable for when that would happen.

Just the same, parties on both sides of the debate have lobbied Health Canada to ensure the study addresses their respective concerns.

For example, CanWEA expressed significant concerns related to the scope and proposed methodology of the study.

In its response to Health Canada’s study, CanWEA noted that Health Canada is proposing to launch an extensive sound-modeling program to derive a “dose-response relationship” between wind turbine sound and adverse health impacts, as well as undertake an undisclosed number of sound-measurement programs intended to validate the model’s results.

"This introduces a significant level of uncertainty into the study and has the potential to undermine the credibility of the study," CanWEA said.

Additionally, CanWEA noted that scientific evidence to date demonstrates that wind turbines do not have an impact on human health - a finding that has been confirmed by numerous independent reviews of scientific literature.

The results are also backed by a growing body of work, including reports by Ontario’s chief medical officer of health, the National Public Health Institute in Quebec and an expert panel convened by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection.

The concerns about the study's methodology and direction underscore the growing challenges faced by the Canadian wind energy industry - particularly in Ontario, where a vocal minority continues to oppose wind project development.

Sherry Lange - CEO of the North American Platform Against Windpower, an opposition group that filed more than 25 comments in response to the Health Canada study - is urging Health Canada to expedite the processing of responses and calling for a moratorium on wind energy, pending the results of the Health Canada study.

"We applaud Health Canada's effort," she says, "but if the agency is going to take two to three years and devote $1.8 million in funding, [Canada] should not put up any more wind turbines."


IowaDeptEconDevel_id1863

Trachte Inc._id1770
Latest Top Stories

Kansas Renewables Mandate Survives Yet Another Attack, But Is It Too Early To Celebrate?

Over the past three years, some legislators have tried to either weaken or repeal the state's renewable portfolio standard, which requires Kansas utilities to reach 20% renewables by 2020.


AWEA Highlights U.S. Wind Success Stories Of 2013

Despite a 92% drop in new capacity last year, the sector still has myriad reasons to celebrate, according to a new report from the American Wind Energy Association.


Feds List New Bird Species As Threatened - Should Wind Developers Be Worried?

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is designating the lesser prairie-chicken as threatened under the Endangered Species Act. An expert explains how this might affect the wind industry.


Senate Committee Passes Bill With Two-Year PTC Extension

The Senate Finance Committee has voted on a tax extenders package, which includes both the production tax credit (PTC) and investment tax credit, and sent it to the floor.


Five Common Gearbox Failures And How To Identify Them

Wind turbine gearbox failures are a major source of unplanned maintenance costs. An expert explains the most frequent failure modes and offers prevention tips.

UEA_id1896
WomenofWind_id
Acciona_id1907
JLG_id1900
bonfiglioli_id1913
AWEA_id1886